How far should an embodied system change after unexpected experience? Research OS, Mismatch Lab, and Builder Lab by Seonhye Gu.
Updated: 2026-07-29 · Working paper:
paper001_recoverability_complete.pdf
Program: publication-grade proper run ·phase_c_proper_run_prereg_v2.0.md
Same-state counterfactual profiles @ fixed mismatch S separate intervention classes — REPLAN 19/20 vs CONTINUE 0/20 @ 6 cm + occlusion (D0). Multi-mode best (95%) beats UQ-inspired binary rule (0% success · 20/20 handover) and situation rule REOBSERVE path (85%) on pre-registered success metric (D2–D3).
| Phase | Content | Status |
|---|---|---|
| A | Smoke atlas 001A–D | ✅ Tier B |
| B | Desk review | ✅ |
| C v1.0 | D0 primary cell | ✅ 2026-07-22 |
| C v2.0 | D1–D3 baselines + control | ✅ 2026-07-24 VESSL |
| Lit v2 | Positioning | ✅ |
| Next | Working paper · venue · Fig baseline overlay | ⏭ paper001_recoverability_complete.pdf |
| Paper 002 | WM expansion design · L1 vs L3 · Ep1/Ep2 | 🔄 pre-reg draft · ../paper002/status.md |
| Mode | Success (n=20) | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| CONTINUE | 0/20 | |
| REPLAN_d20 | 19/20 (95%) | Primary contrast |
| REOBSERVE | 17/20 (85%) | Exploratory |
| RESHAPE | 18/20 (90%) | Exploratory |
| HANDOVER | 0/20 | Stub |
| Block | Sub-RQ | Result (n=20 unless noted) |
|---|---|---|
| D1 no occlusion | RQ-P | CONTINUE 1/20 · REPLAN 19/20 — REPLAN unchanged vs D0; CONTINUE 0→1 descriptive |
| D2 B2 UQ rule | RQ-B | HANDOVER 20/20 · success 0/20 (vis rule always fires @ L1) |
| D3 B3 situation rule | RQ-B | REOBSERVE 17/20 (85%) — matches D0 REOBSERVE arm |
RQ-B (pre-reg Option A): best-of-menu 95% > B2 0% · 95% > B3 85% · direction met.
branch_replay_ok: 80/80 · study1_proper_v2/summary.json
| Tier | Evidence |
|---|---|
| C confirmatory | D0 + D1–D3 · n=20 per branch · pre-reg v2.0 |
| B smoke | 001A–D design input only |
| Study | Report |
|---|---|
| 001A–D | exp_surg_001_execute_or_defer/ |