How far should an embodied system change after unexpected experience? Research OS, Mismatch Lab, and Builder Lab by Seonhye Gu.
Status: EXECUTED · 2026-07-24 · D1–D3 complete ·
study1_proper_v2/summary.json
RQ · method:research_question.mdv1.1 ·method_spec_v1.0.md
Publication-grade Paper 001 = v1.0 D0 (done) + v2.0 D1–D3 (this document).
| Block | Content | Status |
|---|---|---|
| D0 | 5-mode menu @ 6 cm + occlusion L1 | ✅ EXECUTED 2026-07-22 · do not re-run |
| D1 | No-occlusion control @ 6 cm | scheduled post-freeze |
| D2 | B2 UQ-inspired binary | scheduled post-freeze |
| D3 | B3 situation rule | scheduled post-freeze |
| ID | Hypothesis | Block |
|---|---|---|
| RQ-M | REPLAN_d20 ≫ CONTINUE @ anchor | D0 ✅ |
| RQ-P | Occlusion changes CONTINUE/REPLAN vs shift-only @ 6 cm | D1 vs D0 |
| RQ-B | Multi-mode best ≥ B2 or B3 on success or burden | D0 + D2 + D3 |
| RQ-C | REOBSERVE/RESHAPE viable | D0 exploratory |
Successful resolution: shifted target ≤ 0.02 m · no forbidden violation · not handover stub.
D0 (reported): REPLAN 19/20 vs CONTINUE 0/20.
v2.0 contrasts: RQ-P (D1 directional) · RQ-B (D2/D3 vs D0 menu).
Task IK-Rel · onset 20 · shift +0.06 m Y · replan delay 20 · n=20 seeds 0–19 · Isaac 4.1.
| Block | Runner | Branches |
|---|---|---|
| D1 | orbit_reach_study1a_counterfactual.py · no occlusion |
40 |
| D2 | study1d --baseline b2 |
20 |
| D3 | study1d --baseline b3 |
20 |
Launcher: scripts/run_study1_proper_v2.sh · STUDY1_PROPER_BLOCK=d1|d2|d3.
B2 constants: VIS_THRESH=0.5 · DIST_THRESH=0.15 m · check @ t0+10.
B3: occluded_shift → REOBSERVE · shift_only → REPLAN_d20 · else CONTINUE.
RQ-B primary metric (Option A): success rate — D0 best-of-menu (REPLAN, REOBSERVE, RESHAPE) vs B2 and vs B3.
Secondary: HANDOVER burden · Wilson CI · violation rate · RQ-P descriptive D0 vs D1.
branch_replay_ok 100% · promote results/study1_proper_v2/80 branches · ~0.5–0.75 pod-day · VESSL or RunPod.
D0 re-run · Study 002 · delay grid · learned UQ · clinical.
| Version | Date | Note |
|---|---|---|
| v2.0-draft | 2026-07-24 | Initial draft |
| v2.0 | 2026-07-24 | Frozen · GPU accelerated 2026-07-25 · 7d wait waived |