After the Spill

How far should an embodied system change after unexpected experience? Research OS, Mismatch Lab, and Builder Lab by Seonhye Gu.

View the Project on GitHub higuseonhye/research-os

Paper 1 — Phase C proper-run pre-registration v2.0

Status: EXECUTED · 2026-07-24 · D1–D3 complete · study1_proper_v2/summary.json
RQ · method: research_question.md v1.1 · method_spec_v1.0.md


0. Scope

Publication-grade Paper 001 = v1.0 D0 (done) + v2.0 D1–D3 (this document).

Block Content Status
D0 5-mode menu @ 6 cm + occlusion L1 ✅ EXECUTED 2026-07-22 · do not re-run
D1 No-occlusion control @ 6 cm scheduled post-freeze
D2 B2 UQ-inspired binary scheduled post-freeze
D3 B3 situation rule scheduled post-freeze

1. Research questions (v1.1)

ID Hypothesis Block
RQ-M REPLAN_d20 ≫ CONTINUE @ anchor D0 ✅
RQ-P Occlusion changes CONTINUE/REPLAN vs shift-only @ 6 cm D1 vs D0
RQ-B Multi-mode best ≥ B2 or B3 on success or burden D0 + D2 + D3
RQ-C REOBSERVE/RESHAPE viable D0 exploratory

2. Primary endpoint

Successful resolution: shifted target ≤ 0.02 m · no forbidden violation · not handover stub.

D0 (reported): REPLAN 19/20 vs CONTINUE 0/20.

v2.0 contrasts: RQ-P (D1 directional) · RQ-B (D2/D3 vs D0 menu).


3. Shared anchor

Task IK-Rel · onset 20 · shift +0.06 m Y · replan delay 20 · n=20 seeds 0–19 · Isaac 4.1.


4. Blocks D1–D3

Block Runner Branches
D1 orbit_reach_study1a_counterfactual.py · no occlusion 40
D2 study1d --baseline b2 20
D3 study1d --baseline b3 20

Launcher: scripts/run_study1_proper_v2.sh · STUDY1_PROPER_BLOCK=d1|d2|d3.

B2 constants: VIS_THRESH=0.5 · DIST_THRESH=0.15 m · check @ t0+10.
B3: occluded_shift → REOBSERVE · shift_only → REPLAN_d20 · else CONTINUE.


5. Analysis (frozen)

RQ-B primary metric (Option A): success rate — D0 best-of-menu (REPLAN, REOBSERVE, RESHAPE) vs B2 and vs B3.

Secondary: HANDOVER burden · Wilson CI · violation rate · RQ-P descriptive D0 vs D1.


6. Success criteria


7. GPU budget

80 branches · ~0.5–0.75 pod-day · VESSL or RunPod.


8. Out of scope

D0 re-run · Study 002 · delay grid · learned UQ · clinical.


Version

Version Date Note
v2.0-draft 2026-07-24 Initial draft
v2.0 2026-07-24 Frozen · GPU accelerated 2026-07-25 · 7d wait waived