How far should an embodied system change after unexpected experience? Research OS, Mismatch Lab, and Builder Lab by Seonhye Gu.
Core question: How should unexpected experience change an embodied system?
After the Spill studies decision-making after unexpected experience in embodied systems. It asks when a system should preserve its current model, recover within it, repair parameters, expand representation, or coordinate multiple recovery operators.
The program is built to survive individual paper outcomes. A paper may fail, but the foundation documents should continue to clarify the question.
Given an unexpected experience, what is the smallest change that restores competent action without hiding the evidence that made change necessary?
One compact decision form is:
c* = argmin_c [task loss + change cost + risk + future cost]
where c ranges over the available change operators.
| Object | Working role |
|---|---|
| Experience | A situated event that violates, stresses, or confirms the current model |
| Evidence | Information extracted from experience that bears on adequacy |
| Operator | A change action applied to state, policy, model, representation, or coordination |
| Closure | A test that the chosen change is sufficient for the current task boundary |
| Competence | The ability to act successfully under the relevant post-experience conditions |
The decision is not "learn or do not learn." It is a choice among change operators with different costs and risks.
| Operator | Meaning | Typical failure if overused |
|---|---|---|
| Preserve | Record the episode without permanent adaptation | Ignores real mismatch |
| Recover | Restore competent behavior without changing the model | Treats inadequacy as disturbance |
| Repair | Update parameters or local policy within the current representation | Overfits inside the wrong model |
| Expand | Add a prepared mode, relation, entity, constraint, or representation | Invents structure too eagerly |
| Coordinate | Select, order, or recruit multiple recovery capabilities | Adds policy complexity without evidence |
| Paper | Decision studied | Program contribution |
|---|---|---|
| Paper 001: Recoverability | Which response restores execution at the same mismatch state? | Defines the post-mismatch recovery window |
| Paper 002: Model Adequacy | When is parameter repair insufficient? | Tests evidence for moving from repair to model-order expansion |
| Paper 003: Representation Expansion | Which representational operator is missing? | Tests mode/relation discrimination and capability expansion |
| Paper 004: Experience Disposition | How much should an experience change the system? | Classifies ignore, preserve, recover, repair, expand, and escalate decisions |
| Paper 005: Recovery Orchestration | How should multi-relation consequences be contained and resolved? | Studies ordered operator choice under uncertainty |
Capability recruitment is a Paper 005 mechanism, not a separate paper. Ecosystem adaptation remains a long-term open problem.
| ID | Title | Immediate question |
|---|---|---|
| D000 | Mathematical Foundation | What are the program's stable objects? |
| D001 | Claim & Novelty Audit | Is this already Active Inference, Continual Learning, Meta Learning, Recovery Planning, Resilience Engineering, Self-healing Systems, Adaptive Control, or Decision Theory? |
| D002 | Literature Matrix | Can every paper be read through experience, change, decision, evidence, and closure? |
| D003 | Terminology | Which words are allowed, and what do they mean? |
| D004 | Formal Definitions | What must be defined before experiments can claim anything? |
| D005 | Unified Evaluation Protocol | What counts as evidence that an operator was sufficient? |
| D006 | Research Roadmap | How do papers and products accumulate into one program? |
The program evaluates decisions, not only outcomes. A system that succeeds after unnecessary expansion may still be making a bad change decision. A system that fails after refusing expansion may have learned the boundary of repair.
Every study should measure whether the amount of change was justified:
Current evidence supports controlled simulation claims. It does not support clinical deployment, autonomous self-improvement, general intelligence, universal resilience, arbitrary causal discovery, unbounded world-model expansion, or a solution to continual learning.
The line "intelligence chooses the smallest sufficient change" is a governing principle and an audit target. It becomes a scientific claim only where evidence and closure tests make it measurable.
Intelligence is the ability to determine the smallest sufficient change after unexpected experience.
Build less. Break more. Keep what survives.
The program should become harder to fool over time.
Living document - 2026-08-04