How far should an embodied system change after unexpected experience? Research OS, Mismatch Lab, and Builder Lab by Seonhye Gu.
Date: 2026-07-22 · Status: post Lit Sprint v2 · smoke-informed · not a survey
Prior work strong on separate axes: uncertainty-gated handover in surgery, binary task–recovery switching, autonomous exploration recovery, tissue reshaping for exposure (MEDiC), and situation-driven replanning stacks (VAP-TAMP). None standardize same-state counterfactual comparison of a multi-mode intervention menu toward successful resolution with explicit timing. Our Stage 1 contribution is an evaluation protocol and empirical profiles ( \hat{R}_a(s,t) ) on an ORBIT-Surgical reach proxy — smoke evidence (n=5) shows mode separation under shift and an occlusion proxy; confirmatory runs are pre-registered separately (Phase C).
| Line | They optimize | Our wedge |
|---|---|---|
| Surgical UQ | continue vs handover | Multi-mode profile @ same onset |
| Recovery RL / RTA | task ↔ backup policy | Menu + reshape + reobserve |
| MEDiC | tissue reshape for exposure | Reshape as one timed mode among many |
| VAP-TAMP | situation → perceive → replan | Eval not new stack |
| VLA / FM | task success | No public multi-mode recovery profile tables |
Kill test (Day-1 + smoke): full combination → 0 Kill · refine positioning, do not claim empty field.
research_question.mdphase_b_smoke_review.mdphase_c_proper_run_prereg_v1.0.mdroadmap.md