# Paper 002: Failure-Conditioned Model-Order Expansion

> Status: confirmatory complete; venue-neutral submission package v1.1 built
>
> Frozen preregistration: `paper002-model-order-confirmatory-v1.0`
>
> Result artifact: `73a7e16`

## Headline Result

In a complete 400-cell Isaac Sim confirmatory grid, the gated
constant-velocity model reduced H=10 prediction error by 10.806 mm and
fixed-horizon final distance by 13.304 mm relative to repaired zero order.
Both crossed-bootstrap 95% intervals cleared the preregistered 5 mm criterion.
Static retention and all gate-specificity controls passed.

## Start Here

| Document | Purpose |
| --- | --- |
| [Manuscript v1.1](paper002_manuscript_model_order_v1.1.md) · [LaTeX](paper002_manuscript_model_order_v1.1.tex) · [PDF](paper002_manuscript_model_order_v1.1.pdf) | Submission-oriented review manuscript |
| [Supplement v1.1](paper002_supplement_model_order_v1.1.md) · [LaTeX](paper002_supplement_model_order_v1.1.tex) · [PDF](paper002_supplement_model_order_v1.1.pdf) | Conditions, validity audit, full tables, and statistical details |
| [Overleaf main ZIP](paper002_overleaf_main_v1.1.zip) · [supplement ZIP](paper002_overleaf_supplement_v1.1.zip) | Root-`main.tex` upload packages for separate Overleaf projects |
| [BibTeX](paper002_references_v1.1.bib) | Verified submission bibliography |
| [Status](status.md) | Current phase, decisions, and next publication work |
| [Frozen preregistration](paper002_model_order_confirmatory_prereg_v1.0.md) | Fresh sample, endpoints, and locked decision rules |
| [Confirmatory result](../../experiments/surgical_intelligence/exp_surg_003_wm_expansion/results/isaac_model_order_confirmatory_v1.0/RESULTS.md) | Exact accounting, estimates, intervals, and provenance |
| [Figures and CSV tables](figures/README.md) | Reproducible manuscript panels and machine-readable tables |
| [Process-isolated pilot](../../experiments/surgical_intelligence/exp_surg_003_wm_expansion/results/isaac_model_order_pilot_v0.3/RESULTS.md) | Excluded engineering calibration |
| [Model-order protocol v0.3](paper002_model_order_protocol_v0.3.md) | Isolation amendment that closed simulator carryover |
| [Related work v0.2](paper002_related_work_v0.2.md) | Positioning and bibliography checklist |
| [Physical validation roadmap](paper002_physical_validation_roadmap_v0.1.md) | Deferred hardware evidence track |

## Confirmatory Design

```text
Static-first seed selection
  -> shared Ep1 persistent drift
  -> best allowed zero-order parameter repair
  -> persistent/directional/CV-explainable residual gate
  -> A frozen order 0 | B repaired order 0 | C gated order 1 | D oracle
  -> 10 fresh seeds x 10 fresh drift conditions x 4 arms
  -> static retention and gate controls
```

All arms use the same scripted Cartesian controller. The model's H=10 forecast
is the controller target. Every seed-arm-condition cell runs in a fresh Isaac
process.

## Confirmatory Summary

| Endpoint | B repaired zero order | C gated constant velocity | C-B |
| --- | ---: | ---: | ---: |
| H=10 prediction error | 18.401 mm | 7.595 mm | -10.806 mm, 95% CI [-11.360, -10.331] |
| Fixed-horizon final distance | 18.905 mm | 5.601 mm | -13.304 mm, 95% CI [-13.599, -12.982] |
| 20 mm resolution rate | 76% | 100% | +0.24, secondary |
| Static retention | 10/10 | 10/10 | non-inferior |

Gate activation was 100/100 on persistent drift and 0/100 on each of static,
observation-noise, and single-impulse controls. There were no missing cells,
unexpected resets, or forbidden-region violations.

## Reproduce Derived Materials

No simulator or GPU is required to recreate the paper figures and CSV tables:

```bash
python scripts/plot_paper002_model_order.py
python scripts/build_paper002_submission_tex.py
python scripts/build_paper002_overleaf_zip.py
python scripts/build_paper002_submission_pdf.py
```

The generated `.tex` files are standalone venue-neutral sources. From
`docs/paper002`, a standard BibTeX build for the main manuscript is:

```bash
pdflatex paper002_manuscript_model_order_v1.1.tex
bibtex paper002_manuscript_model_order_v1.1
pdflatex paper002_manuscript_model_order_v1.1.tex
pdflatex paper002_manuscript_model_order_v1.1.tex
```

The supplement has no bibliography and requires two `pdflatex` passes. No TeX
engine is bundled with this repository.

### Upload To Overleaf

Use the ZIP packages rather than uploading the standalone `.tex` file from the
project dashboard:

1. In Overleaf, select **New Project** and then **Upload Project**.
2. Upload `paper002_overleaf_main_v1.1.zip` for the manuscript.
3. Confirm **Compiler: pdfLaTeX** and **Main document: main.tex** in Settings.
4. Upload `paper002_overleaf_supplement_v1.1.zip` as a separate project when a
   separately compiled supplement is required.

Both archives place `main.tex` at the ZIP root. The manuscript archive also
contains the BibTeX database and all five referenced PNG figures.

The Isaac experiment itself should run only on the documented VESSL image and
frozen source/config. See [the VESSL runbook](vessl_runbook_v0.1.md).

## Claim Boundary

Supported: in the specified Isaac target-drift family, structured failure after
zero-order repair warrants a prepared velocity-state expansion that improves
prediction-linked control without static regression.

Not supported: unconstrained model invention, arbitrary world-model expansion,
tissue/contact validity, hardware transfer, clinical efficacy, or operating-
room deployment.

Historical mock-to-physics documents remain under
[`archive/mock_to_physics`](archive/mock_to_physics/README.md) and must not be
cited as Paper 002 evidence.
